Billy Corgan, the Smashing Pumpkins frontman, has accused the late Scott Weiland of ripping off a Pumpkins music for Stone Temple Pilots’ hit “Plush.” Yeah, you heard that proper.
However is there any reality to this declare, or is Billy simply stirring the pot?
Let’s dive in.
Throughout The Magnificent Others with Billy Corgan podcast, Billy spoke with the DeLeo brothers, Stone Temple Pilot’s guitarist and bassist. Billy claimed that the enduring “And I really feel, and I really feel” line in “Plush” was lifted from the Pumpkins’ music “Undergo.”
He mentioned he was watching MTV, heard “Plush,” and thought it was ripped. However right here’s the kicker: the road in “Undergo” goes, “And also you’re feeling, you’re feeling, you’re feeling, you want your self.”
Now, let’s speak concerning the songs themselves.
“Undergo” is a deep reduce from the Pumpkins’ 1991 album “Gish.” It’s a moody, atmospheric monitor that showcases Billy’s signature whine. “Plush,” however, is a grunge anthem from STP’s 1992 debut “Core.” It’s acquired that driving rhythm, haunting vocals, and a refrain that’s been caught in our heads for many years.
Evaluating the 2, it’s onerous to see the connection. The melodies, lyrics, and total vibes are fairly totally different.
However Billy’s not backing down.
He even admitted, “Good rip although.”
However right here’s the factor: Scott Weiland isn’t right here to defend himself. He handed away in 2015, forsaking a legacy of highly effective performances and unforgettable songs.